For more on how much I LOVE this mascara, check out my Maybelline Colossal mascara review. —Haley
Promising reviews: “This has been my favorite since it came out, like, 10 years ago. I’ve tried every other mascara, and I always come back to this one. It lasts long, has good color, and doesn’t flake/clump. I prefer volume over length, and this delivers. It’s the best mascara. It’s easy to layer, too.” —LH
“Nothing works quite as well! I’ve tried more expensive mascaras, and when it comes to single coats, they can do pretty well. However, this mascara’s strength is in how buildable it is — a couple of coats can take me from zero to ‘are you wearing false lashes?‘” —S. Mcwalters
Get it from Amazon for $7.59.